Payson, AZ Area — Investment Cash Flow Analysis

Single family homes  |  2+ bed / 1.5+ bath / under $300K  |  Within 50 miles of Payson, AZ  |  20% down / 6% / 30yr  |  Rental comps: apt complexes within 10mi scaled by sqft  |  March 2026

Total Analyzed
169
Cash Flow +
6
Cash Flow −
163
Avg Positive CF
$+568/mo
Best CF
$+964/mo
Best CoC
89.0%
AddressCityDistPriceBed/BaSqftBuiltHOA/moDOMEst. RentTotal CostCash FlowCoCDown Pmt
#1 107 E Bonita St St #16, Payson 85541Payson0.4mi$65,0002bd/2.0ba9601997$0110$1,612
14 comps		$648
↳ $312 mtg		$+964+89.0%$13,000
#2 424 W Blackberry Ln, Payson 85541Payson9.8mi$449,0004bd/3.0ba2,5401974$0463$3,617 ⚠
1 comps		$2,704
↳ $2,154 mtg		$+913+12.2%$89,800
#3 308 W Rim View Rd, Payson 85541Payson0.4mi$530,0004bd/3.5ba2,9382014$061$3,998 ⚠
2 comps		$3,138
↳ $2,542 mtg		$+860+9.7%$106,000
#4 1401 N Woodland Dr Unit A, Payson 85541Payson1.9mi$365,0003bd/2.0ba1,8611965$014$2,719 ⚠
4 comps		$2,254
↳ $1,751 mtg		$+465+7.6%$73,000
#5 103 S Overland Ct, Payson 85541Payson0.8mi$598,0004bd/3.0ba2,6551996$297$3,613 ⚠
2 comps		$3,504
↳ $2,868 mtg		$+109+1.1%$119,600
#6 505 N William Tell Cir, Payson 85541Payson1.3mi$389,7503bd/3.0ba1,6561976$01$2,486 ⚠
4 comps		$2,387
↳ $1,869 mtg		$+99+1.5%$77,950
AddressCityDistPriceBed/BaSqftBuiltHOA/moDOMEst. RentTotal CostCash FlowCoCDown Pmt
107 E Bonita St St #16, Payson 85541Payson0.4mi$65,0002bd/2.0ba9601997$0110$1,612
14 comps		$648
↳ $312 mtg		$+964+89.0%$13,000
424 W Blackberry Ln, Payson 85541Payson9.8mi$449,0004bd/3.0ba2,5401974$0463$3,617 ⚠
1 comps		$2,704
↳ $2,154 mtg		$+913+12.2%$89,800
308 W Rim View Rd, Payson 85541Payson0.4mi$530,0004bd/3.5ba2,9382014$061$3,998 ⚠
2 comps		$3,138
↳ $2,542 mtg		$+860+9.7%$106,000
1401 N Woodland Dr Unit A, Payson 85541Payson1.9mi$365,0003bd/2.0ba1,8611965$014$2,719 ⚠
4 comps		$2,254
↳ $1,751 mtg		$+465+7.6%$73,000
103 S Overland Ct, Payson 85541Payson0.8mi$598,0004bd/3.0ba2,6551996$297$3,613 ⚠
2 comps		$3,504
↳ $2,868 mtg		$+109+1.1%$119,600
505 N William Tell Cir, Payson 85541Payson1.3mi$389,7503bd/3.0ba1,6561976$01$2,486 ⚠
4 comps		$2,387
↳ $1,869 mtg		$+99+1.5%$77,950
912 W Summit St, Payson 85541Payson0.9mi$374,9903bd/2.0ba1,4851929$034$2,291 ⚠
4 comps		$2,308
↳ $1,799 mtg		$-17-0.3%$74,998
207 E Aero Dr, Payson 85541Payson0.2mi$319,0004bd/2.0ba1,4551966$016$1,980 ⚠
2 comps		$2,008
↳ $1,530 mtg		$-28-0.5%$63,800
101 N Forest Park Dr, Payson 85541Payson0.8mi$375,0002bd/2.0ba1,7281990$839$2,220
14 comps		$2,316
↳ $1,799 mtg		$-96-1.5%$75,000
607 E Drowsey Cir, Payson 85541Payson1.7mi$320,0002bd/2.0ba1,2801980$046$1,914
14 comps		$2,014
↳ $1,535 mtg		$-99-1.9%$64,000
209 N Heritage Ln, Payson 85541Payson1.3mi$395,0003bd/3.0ba1,4461997$011$2,247 ⚠
4 comps		$2,415
↳ $1,895 mtg		$-168-2.6%$79,000
404 W Frontier St, Payson 85541Payson0.4mi$475,0004bd/2.0ba1,9201960$0124$2,613 ⚠
2 comps		$2,844
↳ $2,278 mtg		$-231-2.9%$95,000
1120 S Sycamore Cir, Payson 85541Payson0.4mi$472,0003bd/2.0ba1,7482000$3187$2,591 ⚠
4 comps		$2,830
↳ $2,264 mtg		$-240-3.0%$94,400
507 N Manzanita Dr, Payson 85541Payson1.3mi$585,0003bd/2.0ba2,3702004$093$3,158 ⚠
4 comps		$3,433
↳ $2,806 mtg		$-275-2.8%$117,000
700 W Longhorn Rd, Payson 85541Payson0.8mi$390,0003bd/2.0ba1,3221991$2103$2,105 ⚠
4 comps		$2,390
↳ $1,871 mtg		$-285-4.4%$78,000
603 E Amarillo Cir, Payson 85541Payson0.5mi$560,0003bd/2.0ba2,1241990$286$2,982 ⚠
4 comps		$3,301
↳ $2,686 mtg		$-319-3.4%$112,000
125 Tomahawk Rd, Payson 85541Payson9.8mi$359,0003bd/2.0ba1,1401963$027$1,898 ⚠
4 comps		$2,222
↳ $1,722 mtg		$-324-5.4%$71,800
217 W Frontier St, Payson 85541Payson0.2mi$445,0002bd/3.0ba2,0601957$061$2,353
14 comps		$2,683
↳ $2,134 mtg		$-330-4.5%$89,000
414 W Frontier St, Payson 85541Payson0.4mi$419,9003bd/2.0ba1,4121999$043$2,208 ⚠
4 comps		$2,548
↳ $2,014 mtg		$-340-4.9%$83,980
508 S Meadow St, Payson 85541Payson0.3mi$375,0003bd/2.0ba1,2001979$0167$1,967 ⚠
4 comps		$2,308
↳ $1,799 mtg		$-341-5.5%$75,000
1187 W Paint Pony Dr, Payson 85541Payson9.6mi$299,0002bd/1.0ba9001974$03$1,555
14 comps		$1,901
↳ $1,434 mtg		$-346-7.0%$59,800
711 W Summit St, Payson 85541Payson0.7mi$399,9003bd/2.0ba1,3002016$0114$2,080 ⚠
4 comps		$2,441
↳ $1,918 mtg		$-361-5.4%$79,980
2002 E Thunder Mountain Mtn, Payson 85541Payson2.1mi$395,0003bd/2.0ba1,2642022$0116$2,039 ⚠
4 comps		$2,415
↳ $1,895 mtg		$-376-5.7%$79,000
102 S Whiting Dr, Payson 85541Payson0.9mi$579,0003bd/2.0ba2,1831999$0204$3,024 ⚠
4 comps		$3,400
↳ $2,777 mtg		$-376-3.9%$115,800
1112 N Monte Rosa Ln, Payson 85541Payson1.7mi$565,0003bd/3.0ba2,0761995$0278$2,948 ⚠
4 comps		$3,325
↳ $2,710 mtg		$-378-4.0%$113,000
504 W Sherwood Dr, Payson 85541Payson1.6mi$370,0002bd/2.0ba1,2671989$025$1,902
14 comps		$2,281
↳ $1,775 mtg		$-379-6.2%$74,000
208 E Zurich Dr, Payson 85541Payson1.2mi$575,0004bd/4.0ba2,2001978$0174$2,994 ⚠
2 comps		$3,379
↳ $2,758 mtg		$-385-4.0%$115,000
1300 N Navajo Ln, Payson 85541Payson1.9mi$489,0003bd/2.0ba1,6761962$028$2,509 ⚠
4 comps		$2,918
↳ $2,345 mtg		$-410-5.0%$97,800
1506 N Easy St, Payson 85541Payson2.4mi$674,0003bd/3.5ba2,8401994$3294$3,494 ⚠
4 comps		$3,912
↳ $3,233 mtg		$-418-3.7%$134,800
690 N Tonto Rim Loop, Payson 85541Payson15.9mi$489,0002bd/1.0ba1,9201981$25132$2,511 ⚠
1 comps		$2,943
↳ $2,345 mtg		$-433-5.3%$97,800
801 N Madison Dr, Payson 85541Payson2.9mi$648,9003bd/3.0ba2,6241998$088$3,340 ⚠
4 comps		$3,775
↳ $3,112 mtg		$-435-4.0%$129,780
107 W Sherwood Dr, Payson 85541Payson1.6mi$495,0004bd/3.0ba1,8401995$0264$2,504 ⚠
2 comps		$2,951
↳ $2,374 mtg		$-447-5.4%$99,000
169 N Helen Dr, Payson 85541Payson5.0mi$279,9002bd/1.0ba7201974$0134$1,342
14 comps		$1,799
↳ $1,343 mtg		$-457-9.8%$55,980
1504 N Langley Cir, Payson 85541Payson2.2mi$345,0003bd/1.0ba9481962$039$1,680 ⚠
4 comps		$2,147
↳ $1,655 mtg		$-468-8.1%$69,000
247 W Diamond Rd, Payson 85541Payson10.2mi$385,0003bd/1.5ba1,1841959$40132$1,929 ⚠
3 comps		$2,402
↳ $1,847 mtg		$-472-7.4%$77,000
800 N Oak Pt, Payson 85541Payson1.7mi$800,0004bd/2.0ba3,0152011$4215$4,103 ⚠
2 comps		$4,588
↳ $3,837 mtg		$-485-3.6%$160,000
105 N Mogollon Trl, Payson 85541Payson0.9mi$439,0003bd/2.0ba1,3621995$01$2,151 ⚠
4 comps		$2,651
↳ $2,106 mtg		$-500-6.8%$87,800
688 W Cocopah Ln, Payson 85541Payson9.9mi$335,0002bd/2.0ba8641980$031$1,512
14 comps		$2,094
↳ $1,607 mtg		$-582-10.4%$67,000
506 E Jura Cir, Payson 85541Payson1.5mi$374,9002bd/2.0ba1,0671993$0106$1,713
14 comps		$2,307
↳ $1,798 mtg		$-595-9.5%$74,980
303 W Cody Cir, Payson 85541Payson2.8mi$375,0002bd/2.0ba1,0682000$1012$1,714
14 comps		$2,318
↳ $1,799 mtg		$-604-9.7%$75,000
317 E Pine St, Payson 85541Payson0.4mi$365,0002bd/2.0ba1,0002014$0117$1,650
14 comps		$2,254
↳ $1,751 mtg		$-605-9.9%$73,000
164 S Joan Dr, Payson 85541Payson4.9mi$299,0001bd/1.0ba9001964$0180$1,289 ⚠
2 comps		$1,901
↳ $1,434 mtg		$-612-12.3%$59,800
830 W Sherwood Dr, Payson 85541Payson1.5mi$575,0004bd/2.0ba2,0202003$4131$2,749 ⚠
2 comps		$3,383
↳ $2,758 mtg		$-634-6.6%$115,000
314 N Stagecoach Pass Pass, Payson 85541Payson1.2mi$460,0002bd/2.0ba1,5601994$01$2,119
14 comps		$2,763
↳ $2,206 mtg		$-644-8.4%$92,000
804 E Phoenix St, Payson 85541Payson0.8mi$850,0003bd/3.0ba4,3241995$054$4,203 ⚠
4 comps		$4,852
↳ $4,077 mtg		$-649-4.6%$170,000
1140 N Mountain View Ter, Payson 85541Payson13.1mi$474,9002bd/2.0ba1,4992018$03$2,192 ⚠
2 comps		$2,843
↳ $2,278 mtg		$-651-8.2%$94,980
1109 N Gila Dr, Payson 85541Payson1.8mi$419,9992bd/2.0ba1,2562006$09$1,892
14 comps		$2,549
↳ $2,014 mtg		$-657-9.4%$84,000
605 N Bobby Jones Dr, Payson 85541Payson2.5mi$495,0002bd/2.0ba1,9031987$08$2,293
14 comps		$2,951
↳ $2,374 mtg		$-657-8.0%$99,000
511 N Hemlock Cir, Payson 85541Payson1.4mi$465,0002bd/2.0ba1,5471989$0153$2,111
14 comps		$2,790
↳ $2,230 mtg		$-678-8.8%$93,000
2603 E Pine Island Ln, Payson 85541Payson3.0mi$850,0004bd/4.0ba3,2742006$18718$4,356 ⚠
2 comps		$5,039
↳ $4,077 mtg		$-682-4.8%$170,000
181 E Park Rd, Payson 85541Payson13.3mi$350,0002bd/2.0ba1,0161976$023$1,486 ⚠
2 comps		$2,174
↳ $1,679 mtg		$-688-11.8%$70,000
302 W Forest Dr, Payson 85541Payson1.3mi$795,0004bd/3.0ba2,8421982$047$3,867 ⚠
2 comps		$4,557
↳ $3,813 mtg		$-690-5.2%$159,000
1303 N Alpine Heights Dr, Payson 85541Payson2.3mi$549,9003bd/2.0ba1,7172004$3236$2,555 ⚠
4 comps		$3,248
↳ $2,638 mtg		$-692-7.5%$109,980
610 N Wilderness Trl, Payson 85541Payson1.6mi$509,9003bd/2.0ba1,5222003$4152$2,333 ⚠
4 comps		$3,034
↳ $2,446 mtg		$-701-8.2%$101,980
443 W Neal Spur, Payson 85541Payson9.9mi$650,0004bd/2.0ba2,1481964$030$3,059 ⚠
1 comps		$3,781
↳ $3,118 mtg		$-722-6.7%$130,000
1003 N Carefree Cir, Payson 85541Payson1.8mi$575,0003bd/2.0ba1,7981981$07$2,648 ⚠
4 comps		$3,379
↳ $2,758 mtg		$-731-7.6%$115,000
205 S Thunder Mtn, Payson 85541Payson2.1mi$589,0004bd/3.0ba1,9992025$0245$2,720 ⚠
2 comps		$3,454
↳ $2,825 mtg		$-734-7.5%$117,800
1040 S Palomino Pl, Payson 85541Payson7.2mi$369,0002bd/1.0ba9121980$48215$1,566
14 comps		$2,324
↳ $1,770 mtg		$-758-12.3%$73,800
713 N Fox Hill Cir, Payson 85541Payson1.7mi$564,9003bd/2.0ba1,7162005$433$2,554 ⚠
4 comps		$3,329
↳ $2,709 mtg		$-775-8.2%$112,980
177 N Helen Dr, Payson 85541Payson5.0mi$380,0002bd/1.0ba9002010$0495$1,555
14 comps		$2,335
↳ $1,823 mtg		$-780-12.3%$76,000
208 S Brassie Dr, Payson 85541Payson1.8mi$655,0003bd/3.0ba2,1532004$0331$3,003 ⚠
4 comps		$3,807
↳ $3,142 mtg		$-805-7.4%$131,000
818 N Blue Spruce Cir, Payson 85541Payson1.7mi$620,0003bd/2.5ba1,9472007$426$2,817 ⚠
4 comps		$3,624
↳ $2,974 mtg		$-807-7.8%$124,000
102 N Lookout Pt, Payson 85541Payson1.0mi$700,0004bd/3.0ba2,3762017$034$3,233 ⚠
2 comps		$4,048
↳ $3,357 mtg		$-815-7.0%$140,000
182 N Helen Dr, Payson 85541Payson5.0mi$849,9004bd/4.0ba2,9602003$0137$4,028 ⚠
2 comps		$4,851
↳ $4,076 mtg		$-823-5.8%$169,980
605 W St Moritz Dr, Payson 85541Payson1.7mi$480,0002bd/3.0ba1,4301991$0205$2,039
14 comps		$2,870
↳ $2,302 mtg		$-831-10.4%$96,000
1304 N Camelot Dr, Payson 85541Payson2.3mi$510,0002bd/2.0ba1,6881983$39$2,197
14 comps		$3,034
↳ $2,446 mtg		$-837-9.8%$102,000
124 Patriot Dr, Payson 85541Payson6.1mi$735,0003bd/2.5ba2,7291990$185$3,415 ⚠
4 comps		$4,254
↳ $3,525 mtg		$-839-6.8%$147,000
838 S Palomino Way, Payson 85541Payson7.3mi$419,5002bd/1.0ba1,0121983$2452$1,661
14 comps		$2,570
↳ $2,012 mtg		$-909-13.0%$83,900
201 N Mclane Rd, Payson 85541Payson0.9mi$585,0003bd/2.0ba1,6841992$37$2,518 ⚠
4 comps		$3,436
↳ $2,806 mtg		$-918-9.4%$117,000
709 W Old Pine Trl, Payson 85541Payson13.0mi$499,0003bd/1.5ba1,1941989$0303$2,053 ⚠
1 comps		$2,972
↳ $2,393 mtg		$-919-11.1%$99,800
1415 N Alpine Heights Dr, Payson 85541Payson2.5mi$640,0003bd/1.5ba1,9411984$37$2,810 ⚠
4 comps		$3,730
↳ $3,070 mtg		$-920-8.6%$128,000
1410 N Sunset Dr, Payson 85541Payson2.3mi$595,9003bd/2.0ba1,7032025$2247$2,539 ⚠
4 comps		$3,493
↳ $2,858 mtg		$-954-9.6%$119,180
169 N Lee's Way, Payson 85541Payson3.6mi$599,0003bd/2.0ba1,6801986$0315$2,513 ⚠
4 comps		$3,507
↳ $2,873 mtg		$-994-10.0%$119,800
601 E Phoenix St, Payson 85541Payson0.5mi$675,0003bd/2.5ba2,0411996$3306$2,923 ⚠
4 comps		$3,917
↳ $3,238 mtg		$-995-8.8%$135,000
401 W Houston Mesa Rd, Payson 85541Payson2.7mi$525,0002bd/2.0ba1,5622002$1034$2,121
14 comps		$3,121
↳ $2,518 mtg		$-1,001-11.4%$105,000
611 E Hunter Dr, Payson 85541Payson0.5mi$699,0003bd/2.0ba2,1701998$361$3,015 ⚠
4 comps		$4,046
↳ $3,353 mtg		$-1,031-8.8%$139,800
1019 S Ponderosa St, Payson 85541Payson0.3mi$600,0003bd/2.0ba1,6502025$3117$2,479 ⚠
4 comps		$3,516
↳ $2,878 mtg		$-1,037-10.4%$120,000
1428 N Easy St, Payson 85541Payson2.3mi$594,9003bd/2.0ba1,6022025$330$2,424 ⚠
4 comps		$3,489
↳ $2,853 mtg		$-1,064-10.7%$118,980
1201 N Alpine Heights Dr, Payson 85541Payson2.2mi$665,0003bd/2.0ba1,8942018$3111$2,757 ⚠
4 comps		$3,864
↳ $3,190 mtg		$-1,107-10.0%$133,000
1166 N Mountain View Ter, Payson 85541Payson13.1mi$383,9002bd/2.0ba8401960$013$1,228 ⚠
2 comps		$2,356
↳ $1,841 mtg		$-1,127-17.6%$76,780
906 N Autumn Sage Ct, Payson 85541Payson2.5mi$729,0003bd/2.0ba2,3192005$15030$3,121 ⚠
4 comps		$4,354
↳ $3,497 mtg		$-1,232-10.1%$145,800
691 N Pyle Ranch Rd, Payson 85541Payson11.9mi$565,0004bd/2.0ba1,4641994$023$2,085 ⚠
1 comps		$3,325
↳ $2,710 mtg		$-1,241-13.2%$113,000
902 W Lakeview Cir, Payson 85541Payson1.0mi$685,0003bd/2.0ba1,8192004$085$2,671 ⚠
4 comps		$3,968
↳ $3,286 mtg		$-1,297-11.4%$137,000
2018 E Columbine Cir, Payson 85541Payson3.1mi$995,0004bd/3.0ba3,4501999$18775$4,481 ⚠
2 comps		$5,815
↳ $4,772 mtg		$-1,333-8.0%$199,000
259 S Morris Mdws, Payson 85541Payson24.8mi$450,0002bd/1.0ba1,0401973$0121$1,360 ⚠
1 comps		$2,710
↳ $2,158 mtg		$-1,350-18.0%$90,000
1015 N Monarch Dr, Payson 85541Payson1.7mi$869,9003bd/3.0ba2,9892005$0180$3,601 ⚠
4 comps		$4,958
↳ $4,172 mtg		$-1,357-9.4%$173,980
1704 E Snap Dragon Ct, Payson 85541Payson2.5mi$999,9994bd/3.5ba3,4102008$19512$4,453 ⚠
2 comps		$5,850
↳ $4,796 mtg		$-1,397-8.4%$200,000
1101 N Mclane Rd, Payson 85541Payson1.6mi$773,0004bd/2.0ba2,2201987$016$3,021 ⚠
2 comps		$4,439
↳ $3,708 mtg		$-1,418-11.0%$154,600
1106 S Sequoia Cir, Payson 85541Payson0.4mi$688,5003bd/1.5ba1,7002025$3101$2,536 ⚠
4 comps		$3,990
↳ $3,302 mtg		$-1,454-12.7%$137,700
1111 S Sutton Rd, Payson 85541Payson1.8mi$895,0003bd/2.0ba3,0231997$0184$3,625 ⚠
4 comps		$5,092
↳ $4,293 mtg		$-1,467-9.8%$179,000
1210 E Heather Ct, Payson 85541Payson2.6mi$889,0003bd/2.0ba2,9302019$0112$3,559 ⚠
4 comps		$5,060
↳ $4,264 mtg		$-1,502-10.1%$177,800
1303 N Sunshine Ln, Payson 85541Payson2.3mi$869,5003bd/3.0ba2,7001980$390$3,394 ⚠
4 comps		$4,959
↳ $4,170 mtg		$-1,565-10.8%$173,900
803 N Grapevine Cir, Payson 85541Payson3.1mi$699,0003bd/2.5ba1,7562000$195559$2,600 ⚠
4 comps		$4,238
↳ $3,353 mtg		$-1,638-14.1%$139,800
1708 E Snap Dragon Ct, Payson 85541Payson2.5mi$779,0003bd/2.0ba2,1012006$187150$2,965 ⚠
4 comps		$4,658
↳ $3,736 mtg		$-1,693-13.0%$155,800
502 N Wagon Ct, Payson 85541Payson2.0mi$769,5003bd/2.0ba1,8072024$0105$2,658 ⚠
4 comps		$4,420
↳ $3,691 mtg		$-1,763-13.7%$153,900
1112 S Cypress Cir, Payson 85541Payson1.0mi$995,0004bd/2.0ba2,8301996$063$3,851 ⚠
2 comps		$5,628
↳ $4,772 mtg		$-1,777-10.7%$199,000
308 N Nellie Dr, Payson 85541Payson5.1mi$595,0002bd/2.0ba1,0562012$827$1,702
14 comps		$3,494
↳ $2,854 mtg		$-1,792-18.1%$119,000
900 N Autumn Sage Ct, Payson 85541Payson2.5mi$739,9003bd/2.0ba1,7832025$17730$2,630 ⚠
4 comps		$4,439
↳ $3,549 mtg		$-1,809-14.7%$147,980
1105 S Kinzer Ct, Payson 85541Payson1.2mi$824,9003bd/2.0ba2,0172025$0140$2,897 ⚠
4 comps		$4,717
↳ $3,957 mtg		$-1,820-13.2%$164,980
2506 E Feather Plume Ct, Payson 85541Payson2.8mi$829,0003bd/2.5ba2,2722005$187102$3,088 ⚠
4 comps		$4,926
↳ $3,976 mtg		$-1,838-13.3%$165,800
1711 E Velvet Mesquite Ct, Payson 85541Payson2.6mi$700,0002bd/2.5ba1,6442017$085$2,170
14 comps		$4,048
↳ $3,357 mtg		$-1,878-16.1%$140,000
2609 E Pine Island Ln, Payson 85541Payson3.0mi$1,075,0004bd/4.5ba3,2861997$18729$4,365 ⚠
2 comps		$6,243
↳ $5,156 mtg		$-1,879-10.5%$215,000
801 N Scenic Dr, Payson 85541Payson3.4mi$950,0003bd/3.0ba3,0501997$187198$3,644 ⚠
4 comps		$5,574
↳ $4,557 mtg		$-1,930-12.2%$190,000
1607 E Velvet Mesquite Ct, Payson 85541Payson2.5mi$839,0003bd/2.5ba2,0832012$19510$2,953 ⚠
4 comps		$4,988
↳ $4,024 mtg		$-2,035-14.6%$167,800
1100 S Kinzer Ct, Payson 85541Payson1.2mi$889,0003bd/2.0ba2,0172026$0103$2,897 ⚠
4 comps		$5,060
↳ $4,264 mtg		$-2,163-14.6%$177,800
500 N Grapevine Dr, Payson 85541Payson2.5mi$998,0003bd/4.0ba2,9411999$187323$3,566 ⚠
4 comps		$5,831
↳ $4,787 mtg		$-2,265-13.6%$199,600
1705 E Velvet Mesquite Ct, Payson 85541Payson2.6mi$874,9003bd/2.0ba2,0222018$1959$2,903 ⚠
4 comps		$5,180
↳ $4,196 mtg		$-2,277-15.6%$174,980
370 N Coyote Trl, Payson 85541Payson13.5mi$374,9001bd/1.0ba9601958$23173$0 ⚠
0 comps		$2,330
↳ $1,798 mtg		$-2,330-37.3%$74,980
1006 W Knotty Pine Cir, Payson 85541Payson1.6mi$1,150,0004bd/3.0ba3,0462003$755$4,145 ⚠
2 comps		$6,533
↳ $5,516 mtg		$-2,388-12.5%$230,000
195 N Juniper Way, Payson 85541Payson19.5mi$400,0003bd/1.5ba1,0141955$3497$0 ⚠
0 comps		$2,476
↳ $1,919 mtg		$-2,476-37.1%$80,000
604 N Club Dr, Payson 85541Payson3.3mi$1,099,0003bd/3.0ba3,3771997$18731$3,796 ⚠
4 comps		$6,372
↳ $5,271 mtg		$-2,576-14.1%$219,800
811 Gun Crk, Payson 85541Payson15.3mi$425,0003bd/2.0ba1,3782006$0216$0 ⚠
0 comps		$2,576
↳ $2,038 mtg		$-2,576-36.4%$85,000
2802 E Golden Rod Cir, Payson 85541Payson3.7mi$1,050,0003bd/2.5ba2,7831999$1959$3,453 ⚠
4 comps		$6,117
↳ $5,036 mtg		$-2,664-15.2%$210,000
2304 E Blue Bell Cir, Payson 85541Payson3.1mi$1,300,0004bd/4.0ba3,8422005$18747$4,725 ⚠
2 comps		$7,448
↳ $6,235 mtg		$-2,723-12.6%$260,000
228 S Windmill Rd, Payson 85541Payson12.0mi$465,0004bd/3.0ba2,1602009$244$0 ⚠
0 comps		$2,792
↳ $2,230 mtg		$-2,792-36.0%$93,000
466 N Deer Creek Dr, Payson 85541Payson11.7mi$464,9993bd/1.5ba1,7501986$261$0 ⚠
0 comps		$2,792
↳ $2,230 mtg		$-2,792-36.0%$93,000
1611 W Paint Pony Dr, Payson 85541Payson9.2mi$725,0002bd/1.0ba7601979$019$1,389
14 comps		$4,182
↳ $3,477 mtg		$-2,793-23.1%$145,000
1112 S Kinzer Ct, Payson 85541Payson1.2mi$1,049,0003bd/2.0ba2,1932025$019$3,031 ⚠
4 comps		$5,917
↳ $5,031 mtg		$-2,886-16.5%$209,800
2307 E Grapevine Dr, Payson 85541Payson2.7mi$1,150,0003bd/3.0ba3,2222004$187154$3,729 ⚠
4 comps		$6,645
↳ $5,516 mtg		$-2,916-15.2%$230,000
401 S Mariposa St, Payson 85541Payson0.4mi$499,9996bd/3.0ba1,2511981$0122$0 ⚠
0 comps		$2,977
↳ $2,398 mtg		$-2,977-35.7%$100,000
84 W Haught Rd, Payson 85541Payson3.3mi$536,5007bd/2.5ba1,9561974$01$0 ⚠
0 comps		$3,173
↳ $2,573 mtg		$-3,173-35.5%$107,300
367 S River Rd, Payson 85541Payson9.3mi$539,9003bd/2.0ba2,0791991$0286$0 ⚠
0 comps		$3,191
↳ $2,590 mtg		$-3,191-35.5%$107,980
2601 E Golden Aster Cir, Payson 85541Payson3.4mi$1,350,0004bd/4.0ba3,4531998$187180$4,484 ⚠
2 comps		$7,716
↳ $6,475 mtg		$-3,232-14.4%$270,000
2404 W Palmer Dr, Payson 85541Payson2.6mi$1,200,0003bd/2.5ba2,7521998$0249$3,431 ⚠
4 comps		$6,726
↳ $5,756 mtg		$-3,294-16.5%$240,000
608 E Gila Ln, Payson 85541Payson1.8mi$565,0005bd/3.0ba3,1681979$065$0 ⚠
0 comps		$3,325
↳ $2,710 mtg		$-3,325-35.3%$113,000
2204 E Feather Plume Ln, Payson 85541Payson2.6mi$1,425,0004bd/3.5ba4,6262000$187112$4,725 ⚠
2 comps		$8,118
↳ $6,835 mtg		$-3,393-14.3%$285,000
2204 E Feather Plume Ln #543, Payson 85541Payson2.6mi$1,425,0004bd/3.5ba4,6262000$187110$4,725 ⚠
2 comps		$8,118
↳ $6,835 mtg		$-3,393-14.3%$285,000
134 E Belluzzi Blvd, Payson 85541Payson12.6mi$598,0004bd/2.0ba2,1921979$0298$0 ⚠
0 comps		$3,502
↳ $2,868 mtg		$-3,502-35.1%$119,600
1115 N Scenic Dr, Payson 85541Payson3.4mi$1,315,0004bd/4.5ba2,8482025$177420$3,875 ⚠
2 comps		$7,518
↳ $6,307 mtg		$-3,643-16.6%$263,000
193 E Saddle Mountain Rd, Payson 85541Payson14.6mi$624,9993bd/2.0ba1,6321994$0503$0 ⚠
0 comps		$3,647
↳ $2,998 mtg		$-3,647-35.0%$125,000
5304 N Bear Flat Rd, Payson 85541Payson15.4mi$649,9003bd/2.5ba2,7641993$17117$0 ⚠
0 comps		$3,797
↳ $3,117 mtg		$-3,797-35.1%$129,980
7705 N Caballero Rd, Payson 85541Payson4.3mi$1,150,0004bd/3.0ba1,8552016$048$2,524 ⚠
2 comps		$6,458
↳ $5,516 mtg		$-3,934-20.5%$230,000
414 W Main St, Payson 85541Payson0.5mi$1,400,0004bd/2.0ba2,8001992$0676$3,810 ⚠
2 comps		$7,797
↳ $6,715 mtg		$-3,987-17.1%$280,000
316 W Elk Song Trl, Young 85554Young20.4mi$699,0003bd/2.5ba1,8272013$0832$0 ⚠
0 comps		$4,043
↳ $3,353 mtg		$-4,043-34.7%$139,800
396 S Leisure Rd, Payson 85541Payson24.9mi$700,0003bd/2.5ba1,9932017$07$0 ⚠
0 comps		$4,048
↳ $3,357 mtg		$-4,048-34.7%$140,000
228 E Belluzzi Blvd, Payson 85541Payson12.8mi$720,0003bd/2.0ba1,5381984$024$0 ⚠
0 comps		$4,155
↳ $3,453 mtg		$-4,155-34.6%$144,000
1412 E Phoenix St, Payson 85541Payson1.5mi$1,534,0004bd/2.0ba3,1042018$434$4,224 ⚠
2 comps		$8,518
↳ $7,358 mtg		$-4,294-16.8%$306,800
2912 E Chuparosa Cir, Payson 85541Payson3.5mi$1,595,0004bd/4.5ba4,0521997$187220$4,725 ⚠
2 comps		$9,028
↳ $7,650 mtg		$-4,303-16.2%$319,000
199 S Greystone Cir, Payson 85541Payson24.9mi$749,0004bd/2.5ba3,3341994$0185$0 ⚠
0 comps		$4,311
↳ $3,593 mtg		$-4,311-34.5%$149,800
907 W Skyline Cir, Payson 85541Payson1.0mi$1,350,0003bd/2.0ba2,4002025$0171$3,179 ⚠
4 comps		$7,529
↳ $6,475 mtg		$-4,350-19.3%$270,000
7816 W Forest Service Rd #200, Young 85554Young20.5mi$799,0003bd/2.5ba3,0032013$0309$0 ⚠
0 comps		$4,578
↳ $3,832 mtg		$-4,578-34.4%$159,800
1004 N Scenic Dr, Payson 85541Payson3.6mi$1,650,0004bd/4.0ba3,2792026$187108$4,360 ⚠
2 comps		$9,322
↳ $7,914 mtg		$-4,963-18.1%$330,000
1201&1203 W Chatham Dr, Payson 85541Payson1.5mi$1,600,0003bd/3.5ba3,0262012$071$3,627 ⚠
4 comps		$8,868
↳ $7,674 mtg		$-5,240-19.6%$320,000
212 W Homestead Ln, Payson 85541Payson18.6mi$899,0003bd/3.0ba2,6171994$1351$0 ⚠
0 comps		$5,249
↳ $4,312 mtg		$-5,249-35.0%$179,800
178 W Memory Ln, Payson 85541Payson18.4mi$899,0003bd/2.5ba2,7971999$13553$0 ⚠
0 comps		$5,249
↳ $4,312 mtg		$-5,249-35.0%$179,800
828 N Gun Creek Rd, Payson 85541Payson15.3mi$925,0003bd/2.5ba2,2752019$07$0 ⚠
0 comps		$5,253
↳ $4,437 mtg		$-5,253-34.1%$185,000
2706 E Wild Rose Cir, Payson 85541Payson3.5mi$1,799,0004bd/4.0ba4,7802000$1871$4,725 ⚠
2 comps		$10,120
↳ $8,629 mtg		$-5,395-18.0%$359,800
210 N Valley Rd, Payson 85541Payson3.4mi$1,380,0002bd/1.5ba1,2002022$035$1,839
14 comps		$7,690
↳ $6,619 mtg		$-5,851-25.4%$276,000
1103 E Ranch Rd, Payson 85541Payson22.4mi$1,139,0005bd/3.0ba2,3281994$0112$0 ⚠
0 comps		$6,399
↳ $5,463 mtg		$-6,399-33.7%$227,800
248 N Haigler Dr, Young 85554Young20.0mi$1,200,0006bd/6.0ba5,6322000$0183$0 ⚠
0 comps		$6,726
↳ $5,756 mtg		$-6,726-33.6%$240,000
106 S Rim Club Dr, Payson 85541Payson2.0mi$1,895,0003bd/3.0ba2,2882025$283177$3,099 ⚠
4 comps		$10,730
↳ $9,089 mtg		$-7,631-24.2%$379,000
Aspen Plan, Payson 85541Payson2.9mi$1,895,0003bd/3.0ba2,2880$285240$3,099 ⚠
4 comps		$10,732
↳ $9,089 mtg		$-7,633-24.2%$379,000
2207 E Filaree Cir, Payson 85541Payson2.7mi$2,195,0004bd/3.5ba3,6042022$19513$4,591 ⚠
2 comps		$12,249
↳ $10,528 mtg		$-7,658-20.9%$439,000
2209 E Grapevine Dr, Payson 85541Payson2.6mi$2,245,0004bd/5.0ba5,8892003$187143$4,725 ⚠
2 comps		$12,508
↳ $10,768 mtg		$-7,783-20.8%$449,000
1006 W Rock Springs Cir, Payson 85541Payson1.7mi$1,400,0005bd/4.0ba3,4112005$7521$0 ⚠
0 comps		$7,872
↳ $6,715 mtg		$-7,872-33.7%$280,000
Mesquite Plan, Payson 85541Payson2.9mi$2,105,8263bd/3.0ba2,4440$285240$3,211 ⚠
4 comps		$11,861
↳ $10,100 mtg		$-8,650-24.6%$421,165
2316 E Indian Pink Cir, Payson 85541Payson2.6mi$2,350,0003bd/3.5ba3,7002023$1951$3,934 ⚠
4 comps		$13,079
↳ $11,272 mtg		$-9,144-23.4%$470,000
415 E Rim Estates Trl, Payson 85541Payson13.1mi$1,699,9004bd/3.0ba2,7012009$09$0 ⚠
0 comps		$9,403
↳ $8,153 mtg		$-9,403-33.2%$339,980
Juniper Plan, Payson 85541Payson2.9mi$2,485,5974bd/4.0ba3,1780$285240$4,288 ⚠
2 comps		$13,895
↳ $11,922 mtg		$-9,607-23.2%$497,119
2502 E Morning Glory Cir, Payson 85541Payson3.2mi$2,595,0004bd/4.5ba4,2192026$18754$4,725 ⚠
2 comps		$14,383
↳ $12,447 mtg		$-9,658-22.3%$519,000
2800 E Rim Club Dr, Payson 85541Payson2.9mi$2,600,0004bd/5.0ba6,7722005$2922$4,725 ⚠
2 comps		$14,514
↳ $12,471 mtg		$-9,789-22.6%$520,000
108A S Rim Club Dr, Payson 85541Payson2.9mi$2,380,0003bd/3.0ba2,2882025$283121$3,099 ⚠
4 comps		$13,327
↳ $11,415 mtg		$-10,228-25.8%$476,000
Pinion Plan, Payson 85541Payson2.9mi$2,506,5833bd/3.0ba3,1010$285240$3,677 ⚠
4 comps		$14,007
↳ $12,023 mtg		$-10,330-24.7%$501,317
4678 N Bear Flat Rd, Payson 85541Payson15.2mi$1,899,0006bd/4.0ba4,3782001$1754$0 ⚠
0 comps		$10,486
↳ $9,108 mtg		$-10,486-33.1%$379,800
108 S Rim Club Dr, Payson 85541Payson3.0mi$2,795,8724bd/4.0ba3,1782026$29244$4,288 ⚠
2 comps		$15,563
↳ $13,410 mtg		$-11,275-24.2%$559,174
108C S Rim Club Dr, Payson 85541Payson3.0mi$2,795,8724bd/4.0ba3,1782026$29244$4,288 ⚠
2 comps		$15,563
↳ $13,410 mtg		$-11,275-24.2%$559,174
3103 S Monument Peak, Payson 85541Payson3.0mi$2,990,0004bd/4.5ba5,0732026$283355$4,725 ⚠
2 comps		$16,594
↳ $14,341 mtg		$-11,869-23.8%$598,000
Ponderosa Plan, Payson 85541Payson2.9mi$2,995,0004bd/4.0ba4,0520$285240$4,725 ⚠
2 comps		$16,622
↳ $14,365 mtg		$-11,897-23.8%$599,000
6368 N AZ Highway 288 --, Globe 85501Globe46.4mi$2,200,0004bd/2.5ba3,2381989$053$0 ⚠
0 comps		$12,080
↳ $10,552 mtg		$-12,080-33.0%$440,000
Search: SFR within 50 miles of Payson, AZ (34.23°N, 111.32°W) | Cities: Payson, Globe, Miami, Superior, Apache Junction, Queen Creek, San Tan Valley, Coolidge, Florence, Show Low, Pinetop, Snowflake, Winslow
Cost: Mortgage = PMT(6%/12, 360, price×80%)  |  Taxes = price×0.30%/12  |  Insurance = price×0.37%/12  |  HOA per listing  |  Reserves $300/mo  |  PM $0
Rent: Average max rent of apt complexes within 10mi matching bed count, scaled by sqft ratio. SFR typically rents for more — estimates are conservative. ⚠ = fewer than 5 comps.
DOM: 🟢 ≤7d   🟡 8–30d   🔴 30+d